
Photo by Dustin Bradford/Getty Images
Vegas already thinks highly of Hunter and Sanders
BetMGM has released its early NFL Rookie of the Year odds following the 2025 Draft, and two Buffaloes are firmly within the mix.
Headlining all rookies is former Colorado WR/CB Travis Hunter, who’s an early favorite to win Rookie of the Year (RotK), on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball. The 2024 Heisman Trophy winner shined as both a pass catcher and in pass coverage for the Buffs, making this revelation anything but surprising.
At the time of writing this, Hunter’s odds of winning Offensive RotY sit at +550, good for the third-best odds within the category. The two players ranked ahead of him are former Boise State and current Las Vegas Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty (+250) and former Miami and current Tennessee Titans quarterback Cam Ward (+250). Hunter is the highest-ranked wide receiver in that list by a significant margin, as the player with the fourth-highest odds is Panthers receiver Tetairoa McMillan, with odds of +1300.
As for Defensive RotY, Hunter has the second-highest odds of winning the award, with odds of +750. The only player with better odds than Hunter is former Penn State and current Giants edge rusher Abdul Carter, with odds of +250. Although Hunter was selected one pick ahead of Carter, sportsbooks are predicting that Carter is 3x more likely to win Defensive RotY than the former CU cornerback. Two edge rushers, the Falcons’ Jaylon Walker (+900) and 49ers’ Mykel Williams (+1000), sit just behind Hunter, good for ranks three and four.
The reason for the disparity in odds between Carter and Hunter is fairly self-explanatory and non-controversial. Jacksonville Jaguars head coach Liam Coen said publicly on Day 1 of the NFL Draft that the team views Hunter as a wide receiver first and foremost, and a cornerback second. While Coen said that Hunter will get every opportunity to play cornerback in practice, his role on the defensive side of the football for his rookie season is a bit foggy, explaining his lower odds.
Hunter ranks highly in two separate RotY categories for early betting, but the story for former CU quarterback Shedeur Sanders is quite a bit different.
Sanders was the subject of perhaps the most drastic slide in NFL history, as the projected top ten draft pick managed to fall to the fifth round, being selected 144th overall by the Cleveland Browns. Despite falling so far, BetMGM has given Sanders odds of +2500 to win Offensive RotY.
With Sanders’ +2500 odds, sportsbooks believe he’s the 12th most likely player to win the award, despite sliding all the way to the third day of the NFL Draft. Sanders has the third-highest odds between QBs in the category, ranked only below Ward (+250) and New Orleans' Tyler Shough (+2000), and tied with the Giants’ Jaxson Dart (+2500).
Even though six quarterbacks were selected above Sanders, he’ll still get every opportunity to start during this season. Cleveland's quarterback situation is extremely volatile, with Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, Dillon Gabriel and Sanders being brought in to battle for the right to replace Deshaun Watson, whose time in Cleveland hasn’t panned out. Sanders has the talent to win the starting job, but he’ll have to properly showcase it during training camp and the preseason.
Whatever way you slice it, Vegas is relatively high on both Sanders and Hunter, which is hopefully a good omen of things to come in the 2025-26 season.
by RylandScholes
Continue reading...