Totally different situation, I know. Hawkins is gone after this year. He doesn't have a future to play for. There's no upside to him pulling Hirschman's redshirt, because nothing Hawk does will save his job. In fact, pulling the shirt might just put the final nail in his coffin. However, here's another perspective that is worth noting - if we feel comfortable that Berglund will be a Buff. And we're comfortable that he's a legit D-1 QB. Then wouldn't it make sense to give him two years' separation between himself and Hirschman? Food for thought.