Discussion in 'Colorado Football Message Board' started by Duff Man, Nov 24, 2007.
Should win: McFadden
Will win: Tebow
if i had to vote, i really wouldn't know who to put #1 between tebow and mcfadden, they've both have had awesome years.
No seriously, I think McFadden or Tebow is probably gonna win, but if Chase Daniel has a big game tomorrow and then another in the CCG, I think you seriously have to look at him.
I'm really impressed with McFadden, he just tears through creases and battles for every yard.
I don't know if any of you have seen Tebow, but if he gets stopped while running, he just falls down. It's little things like that which make a big difference in my eyes.
Herbstreit made a case for McFadden on Game Day this morning. I like the guy, he backs up all of his picks with facts and not feelings most of the time.
I agree that Daniel should get a long look, but I think he is aided by having more talent around him than McFadden. Both are great players, it's just that McFadden is better.
McFadden is really fun to watch. He is a true all-everything player. Besides Felix Jones, Arkansas really doesn't have anyone else to take the pressure off of McFadden.
Daniel or Ressing. SEC still overrated.
McFadden is the best player in college football.
Jimmy Claussen. Can't win 4 if he doesn't win one this year. :lol:
This might be the hardest year I can remember to pick a winner. Today I would say McFadden. But it's hard to ignore Tebow being the first QB to throw for 20 and rush for 20 TDs. Daniel is as deserving as anyone, but Mizzou didn't push the candidacy early on, so nobody paid attention to him. Then there is Dixon at Oregon, who probably would have been my choice before he got hurt. But missing two games probably takes him out.
I guess if I had to do a top 5, it would probably be:
Don't even talk to me about Ryan or Brennan. Both candidacies are complete jokes...
McFadden, kinda wish the Broncs would have tanked so they had a shot at him.
I'm waiting until all the games are over.. Daniel and Reesing both have a legit shot..
okay tebow #1 on my list.
McFadden. 8 guys in the box every time, they still run, and he still racks up the yards.
Separate names with a comma.