From the Big 12 era, what Buff would you put on that list over who is there? Talib at 10 is really the only one I think shouldn't be there.
Chris Brown or Jordon Dizon are probably our two best players from the B12 era. But, I certainly wouldn't try to argue that CB needs to be on the list over Ricky or AP. Dizon was great, but if Derrick Johnson is at 8, it's not surprising he didn't make it. Maybe you could argue for Dan Graham as well. But, TEs aren't very exciting for lists like that. Ben Kelly was a decent CB and when you added in his return skills, he was pretty good. But top 10? I'm just not remembering any Buffs that absolutely needed to be on this list.
I think they put too many QBs on the list, but that always happens. You could probably take Bishop off. But, he really was very good. I don't see a Buff jumping on ahead of him, however. The Buffs have been relevant for most of the B12 era, but they usually did it without any transcendent talents on the roster.