Heres what I don't get-Dayton has the same number of top 100 wins we do (9). Their best win came against Iowa (RPI 23) on a neutral floor. We'll have three wins after today that are better than that. (I would expect Arizona to move up today after the win over us) Our worst loss was UCLA (101-on the road). They have a loss at home to Rhode Island (RPI 104) and at La Salle (RPI 229).
Iowa also has 9 top 100 wins. They have sweeps of Michigan State and Purdue, which are impressive, but we compare well with the W's over Oregon, Cal, Oregon State (RPI 28), and Arizona. They've also got two bad losses (Illinois-155-which came today, and Penn State-111-who we beat) that are uglier than UCLA.
Wisconsin has 10 top 100 wins, but here's the kicker with them. They're currently losing to the Corn (RPI 170). They have lost to Georgetown, Marquette, and Northwestern (all of whom have worse RPIs than UCLA does). In addition, there are losses on their resume to UW-Milwaukee and Western Illinois. Both of those teams have sub-150 RPIs, and both those losses were at Madison.
I used these two profiles because Jerry Palm has both Dayton and Iowa as 6 seeds. Lunardi is in agreement on Dayton and Iowa, and he's also got Wisconsin as a 6. If you take the names off the front of the jerseys when comparing them to us, what makes Dayton, Iowa, and in Lunardi's case Wisconsin worthy of being 1-2 seed lines higher than us?
This is a great post - and one that I largely agree with. However, there's one aspect that you overlooked. Here's a blind resume test showing each team's records on both neutral sites and road games. Due to pure laziness, I'm using the KenPom ranking of the teams instead of RPI rankings, so do take that in to account as there are some differences between the two systems.
Team #1
Neutral record: 2-1
Neutral wins (opponents KP ranking): #19, #67
Road record: 8-2
Road wins (opponents KP ranking): #26, #72, #93, #100, #161, #167, #205, #241
Team #2
Neutral record: 1-2
Neutral wins (opponents KP ranking): #35
Road record: 6-5
Road wins (opponents KP ranking): #19, #25, #41, #122, #137, #216
Team #3
Neutral record: 2-3
Neutral wins (opponents KP ranking): #137, #193
Road record: 4-7
Road wins (opponents KP ranking): #103, #157, #193, #209
Team #4
Neutral record: 2-3
Neutral wins (opponents KP ranking): #11, #278
Road record: 6-5
Road wins (opponents KP ranking): #3, #15, #56, #105, #122, #290
In order, they are Dayton, Wisconsin, Colorado and Iowa. Our RPI is great, and I have to salute Tad for that, but our neutral/road records suck. The committee does take that into account too because these tourney games will be played in neutral sites. Honestly, this is the only thing that's keeping me up at night in regards to us dancing. I'm pretty sure I'm chicken little here, but I'm still a little nervous. A win yesterday would have been huge.